Review gating: how the Google and FTC rules differ
Google expressly prohibits selectively soliciting positive reviews. The FTC rule covers related deceptive conduct, but it is not accurate to treat every review-gating scenario as the same federal-rule violation.
Do not use review gating on Google. Google's Maps policy tells merchants not to discourage negative reviews or selectively solicit positive reviews. The FTC's 2024 rule separately addresses fake reviews, incentives conditioned on sentiment, specified threats and false accusations, and certain suppression by sites that display reviews.
What is review gating?
Review gating is any process that screens customers before deciding who gets asked for a public review, or that diverts dissatisfied customers away from public review sites. It usually looks harmless:
- A survey that only sends happy customers to your Google review link.
- Asking "how was your experience?" first, then forwarding only the positive answers to Google and the rest to a private inbox.
- Filtering, hiding, or delaying negative reviews so your public rating looks better than reality.
The line is simple: asking every customer for a public review is fine. Deciding who to ask based on how they feel is not.
What the law actually says
The FTC rule (federal law, since October 2024)
The FTC's Rule on the Use of Consumer Reviews and Testimonials took effect October 21, 2024. It addresses fake or false reviews, buying reviews that must express a particular sentiment, undisclosed insider reviews, company-controlled review sites presented as independent, specified threats or false accusations used to suppress reviews, and certain suppression by businesses that operate review sections.
Courts may impose civil penalties for knowing violations. The amount is adjusted over time, and whether conduct violates the rule depends on the facts, so confirm current FTC guidance and consult counsel rather than relying on a fixed figure here.
Source: U.S. Federal Trade Commission, Consumer Reviews and Testimonials Rule: Q&A
Google's policy
Google's Maps policy is explicit: merchants must not discourage or prohibit negative reviews or selectively solicit positive reviews. Google may remove violating content and can restrict a Business Profile's ability to receive or display reviews.
Why gating backfires even beyond the law
- It's fragile. One complaint or audit turns a shortcut into a liability, per review.
- Google can suppress gated reviews — you lose the ratings you gamed for.
- Customers can tell. A wall of nothing-but-5-stars with no recent detail reads as managed, not trusted.
How to get more reviews without gating
You don't need gating to win the map pack — you need volume and recency, collected honestly:
- Ask every customer for a public Google review, at the moment they're happiest with your service.
- Never withhold or filter the public review link based on how someone might rate you.
- A private feedback channel is fine — as long as it's offered to everyone as an extra option, not used to divert unhappy customers away from Google.
- Respond to the occasional negative review publicly. A thoughtful reply builds more trust than an unbroken row of five stars.
Review gating FAQ
No. Google's Maps policy says merchants must not discourage negative reviews or selectively solicit positive reviews. Ask customers neutrally and do not decide who receives the public review link based on expected sentiment.
Any process that screens customers before deciding who gets asked for a public review, or that diverts unhappy customers away from Google. Common examples: a survey that only sends happy customers to your Google link, asking how someone feels first and only forwarding the positive ones, or filtering or hiding negative reviews. Asking every customer for a public review is fine; deciding who to ask based on how they feel is not.
You can report a review that violates Google's content policies, but disagreement alone is not grounds for removal. The FTC rule also prohibits specified threats or false accusations used to prevent or remove negative reviews.
Ask every customer for a public Google review, at the moment they are happiest with your service, and never withhold or filter the link. A private feedback channel is fine as long as it is offered to everyone as an extra option, not used to divert unhappy customers away from Google. Risacare Reviews does exactly this: a one-tap public review ask for every customer, no gating.
Risacare Ventures is a US software company. This article is general information about review-related rules, not legal advice; consult a licensed attorney for your situation. Policies and enforcement guidance can change, so confirm them with Google and the FTC.
Every customer gets the same public review ask — no gating. Try Risacare free for 7 days.
Card required · Cancel anytime · No setup fee